City Hall

Lawsuit says Fulton has not turned over records on its $3 million federal water line grant

The founder of the civic group VOTE SoAR has sued the town of Fulton, its mayor and its recorder-treasurer under the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act, saying they only partly answered her requests for records on a $3.05 million federal grant to replace the town's leaking water lines. The town had not filed a response as of Tuesday afternoon.

More from Hope

Quick take

  • Sylvia C. Brown, who leads VOTE SoAR, filed an Arkansas Freedom of Information Act appeal Tuesday, Nov. 10, in Hempstead County Circuit Court against the town of Fulton, Mayor Henry Hale III and Recorder-Treasurer Frances Hendrix, in their official capacities, TXK Today reported.
  • The complaint says she made 10 records requests in May about the town's $3.05 million federal grant to replace water lines and got only an 89-page PDF that answers parts of three of them.
  • She is asking for a hearing within seven days, an order for the town to answer each request in writing and hand over digital copies, and attorney's fees. The town had not filed a response as of Tuesday afternoon.
  • The records included with the lawsuit describe a $3.05 million grant, set aside by Congress in 2023, covering the full cost of replacing water lines, valves and hydrants and rebuilding the sewage pump station at the city park for a system that serves 134 customers.

A south Arkansas civic group leader has gone to court to get records about Fulton's federal water line grant. Sylvia C. Brown, who leads VOTE SoAR, filed an appeal under the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act on Tuesday, Nov. 10, in Hempstead County Circuit Court, TXK Today reported. She sued the town of Fulton, Mayor Henry Hale III and Recorder-Treasurer Frances Hendrix in their official capacities. The case number is 29CV-26-423.

What the lawsuit says

According to the complaint, Brown mailed 10 records requests on May 15. She asked for the mayor's correspondence with Spears Engineering Company, the Texarkana firm on the project, and with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, which runs the grant, along with grant documents and records about a nonresident advisory board for the water system. The complaint says a 2021 state law requires a town water provider to form such a board when at least 20% of its customers live outside town limits.

The complaint says the mayor offered to let her look at records at the water department and later gave her an 89-page PDF, which she had copied onto a thumb drive at a Hope print shop. Her lawyers say that file answers only parts of three of her 10 requests. The complaint says the mayor declined to give her a map of the project area, citing “security issues,” and that Hendrix told her records “were with the auditor.” Brown says she heard nothing more after that.

Brown is asking for a hearing within seven days, as the state records law allows, an order requiring the town to answer each request in writing and turn over digital copies, a judge's review of anything the town says is exempt, and attorney's fees. These are claims in a lawsuit. The town had not filed a response as of Tuesday afternoon, TXK Today reported.

The water project

The records the town did hand over describe a water system built in 1973 that serves 134 customers from two wells and a 50,000 gallon elevated tank. The town says its old asbestos cement mains have had many breaks and leaks.

According to those records, Congress set aside the $3.05 million in the 2023 appropriations act. After the town got a waiver of the usual local match, the grant covers the whole cost, the work plan in the filing says: about $2.83 million to replace water lines, valves and hydrants, and $219,000 to rebuild the sewage pump station at the city park. The grant period runs from Jan. 26, 2026, to June 26, 2027, those records say. EPA emails in the filing show the Osage Nation asked for a cultural resources survey before construction, and that archaeologists expected to spend about 10 days in the field.